Share on Facebook
Share on X
Share on LinkedIn
By Douglas Lipsky
Partner

Your employer owes you money, but the type of legal claim may depend on why the money is owed. In New York, a pay dispute may be a contract claim when an employer breaks an enforceable compensation agreement, while a wage claim generally involves compensation protected by New York wage laws. Some disputes, particularly those involving earned commissions or other promised compensation, may support both contract and wage claims.

What Makes a Pay Dispute a Contract Claim?

A breach-of-contract claim generally arises when an employer fails to honor an enforceable agreement with an employee.

The agreement may be a formal employment contract, an executive agreement, an offer letter, a commission plan, a bonus plan, or another document that establishes compensation rights. A dispute can arise when the employee performs what the agreement requires, but the employer refuses to provide the promised payment.

For example, an executive agreement might promise a specific severance payment following termination without cause. If the employer terminates the executive under circumstances covered by the agreement but refuses to pay, the dispute may involve breach of contract.

Contract claims focus heavily on the language of the agreement: What did each party promise? Were the conditions satisfied? Did the employer fail to perform its obligations?

When Does Unpaid Compensation Become a Wage Claim?

A wage claim arises when an employer fails to pay compensation protected by federal or New York wage laws.

Common examples include unpaid minimum wages, overtime, and certain earned commissions. New York Labor Law also regulates when and how covered employees must be paid and restricts certain deductions from wages.

The key distinction is that wage rights do not necessarily depend on a negotiated employment contract. A nonexempt employee entitled to overtime, for example, generally has that right under wage law, even if an employment agreement says nothing about overtime.

An employer cannot avoid statutory wage obligations simply by leaving them out of a contract.

Can a Bonus or Commission Be Both a Contract and Wage Claim?

Potentially. This is where the distinction becomes less clear.

Suppose an employee has a written commission agreement that provides a specific percentage once a sale meets defined conditions. The employee meets those conditions; the commission is earned, but the employer refuses to pay.

The written agreement may support a claim for breach of contract because the employer failed to honor its promise. Depending on the circumstances, the unpaid commission may also qualify as wages protected by New York Labor Law.

Bonuses require similar analysis. A truly discretionary bonus generally differs from compensation tied directly to an employee’s performance under predetermined criteria. The fact that an employer labels compensation a “bonus” does not by itself determine whether it qualifies as wages.

What About Salary and Executive Compensation Disputes?

Not every unpaid compensation dispute involving a highly paid employee automatically becomes a statutory wage claim.

Executives may have agreements covering base salary, annual incentives, equity, deferred compensation, transaction bonuses, severance, or change-in-control payments. Some disputes involving these forms of compensation are primarily contractual.

The distinction matters because New York wage-law protections do not necessarily apply to every type of executive compensation in the same way.

An attorney reviewing an executive pay dispute should therefore examine both the employment agreement and the statutes that may protect the particular compensation at issue.

What Documents Help Determine Which Claim You Have?

Pay disputes are often document-driven. Before determining whether a matter involves contract rights, wage rights, or both, gather records showing how compensation was structured.

Helpful documents may include:

  • Offer letters and employment agreements
  • Bonus and commission plans
  • Executive compensation agreements
  • Pay stubs and wage statements
  • Time records and schedules
  • Sales and quota reports
  • Emails or texts discussing compensation
  • Amendments to pay terms
  • Termination and severance documents

Prior payment practices may also matter. They can help explain how an employer historically interpreted an ambiguous compensation provision.

When Should You Speak With an Employment Attorney About Unpaid Compensation?

Talk to a lawyer if an employer refuses to pay promised compensation, changes a pay formula after work has been completed, disputes whether a commission or bonus has been earned, or refuses severance required under an employment agreement.

That’s where Lipsky Lowe can assist you. We represent New York City employees, professionals, and executives in wage and contract disputes involving salary, overtime, commissions, bonuses, severance, and other compensation. Contact us today to learn how we can help.

About the Author
Douglas Lipsky is a co-founding partner of Lipsky Lowe LLP. He has extensive experience in all areas of employment law, including discrimination, sexual harassment, hostile work environment, retaliation, wrongful discharge, breach of contract, unpaid overtime, and unpaid tips. He also represents clients in complex wage and hour claims, including collective actions under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act and class actions under the laws of many different states. If you have questions about this article, contact Douglas today.