You close the deal under one commission structure your employer announces a new formula that leaves you with less than you expected. In New York, an employer may be able to change a commission plan going forward, but retroactively reducing a commission that has already been earned can raise serious wage and contract issues. Whether the commission was already earned depends heavily on the written agreement and the conditions required for payment.
When Is a Commission Considered Earned in New York?
This is usually the first question in a commission dispute.
A written commission agreement should explain what an employee must do before a commission becomes earned. Depending on the plan, that event might be signing a customer, completing a sale, closing a transaction, receiving payment from the customer, or satisfying another stated condition.
The date a commission becomes earned is not necessarily the same as the date it is paid. An employee might meet all requirements to earn a commission in October, even though the company’s normal payroll schedule does not issue the payment until December.
That distinction becomes especially important when an employer changes its commission plan between those two dates.
Can an Employer Change a Commission Plan Going Forward?
Employers generally have more flexibility to change commission terms for future work than to alter compensation for work already performed.
For example, an employer might announce that beginning next quarter, the commission percentage for new sales will change. Whether that change is permissible depends on the employment arrangement, applicable law, and any contractual requirements.
The situation is different when an employee completed the work under the existing plan, and the employer later tries to apply the new formula to that transaction.
Employees should keep copies of both the old and new compensation plans and note exactly when the employer announced and implemented the change.
What if My Employer Changes the Formula After I Make the Sale?
A retroactive change may create a dispute if the employee had already satisfied the conditions necessary to earn the commission.
Suppose a salesperson’s agreement provides a 10% commission when a customer signs a contract. The salesperson secures the signed agreement, and the employer subsequently announces that the commission rate is now 6%. Applying that new percentage to an already-earned commission may raise different legal issues than applying it to sales made after the change.
However, commission agreements vary considerably. Some provide that commissions are not earned until the customer pays, the company completes its work, or another condition is met. The actual contract language must be reviewed before determining whether a change was retroactive.
What Should Your Commission Agreement Say?
For certain commissioned salespeople, New York Labor Law requires a written employment agreement describing how wages, salary, drawing accounts, commissions, and other compensation are calculated.
Employees should pay particular attention to provisions addressing:
- The commission rate or formula
- The event that makes a commission earned
- Payment timing
- Customer cancellations or nonpayment
- Chargebacks and deductions
- Changes to the compensation plan
- Pending commissions after resignation or termination
An employer’s description of a commission as “discretionary” or “subject to change” should also be read in the context of the complete agreement.
What Evidence Can Help Prove an Unpaid Commission Claim?
Commission disputes are often document-driven. Employees should preserve records they are lawfully entitled to keep, including the commission agreement, amendments to the plan, offer letters, sales records, customer contracts, commission statements, pay stubs, and communications discussing compensation.
Emails or messages announcing a change can be particularly important because they may establish when the employer modified the plan. Historical commission statements may also show how the company previously calculated payments under the same agreement.
A clear timeline can help establish which compensation plan governed the disputed transaction.
Can an Unpaid Commission Become a Wage Claim?
Yes, depending on the circumstances. Once a commission qualifies as earned wages under the governing agreement and New York law, an employer may face restrictions on withholding or reducing that compensation.
A dispute may also support a breach-of-contract claim when an employer fails to honor an enforceable compensation agreement.
Which claim applies can affect the damages and other remedies available, so distinguishing an anticipated commission from one that was legally earned matters.
Legal Help for Commission Disputes in NYC
Do not assume the employer’s new calculation is automatically valid. Compare the old and new plans, determine when the disputed transaction occurred, and identify the contractual event that triggers the commission.
At Lipsky Lowe, we represent New York City employees in disputes involving unpaid commissions, bonuses, incentive compensation, and other wage claims. We can review the compensation plan and supporting records to determine whether an employer improperly changed the terms governing compensation you had already earned. Contact us today to speak with an experienced unpaid commissions attorney.
