Partner
Employers have a legitimate interest in monitoring workplace activities to ensure productivity, protect company assets, and prevent misconduct. However, employee surveillance is a legally complex issue, particularly in New York, where strict privacy laws protect workers from excessive or unlawful monitoring.
While businesses may track emails, phone calls, and computer usage, they must do so within legal limits. Employers who overstep these boundaries risk lawsuits, regulatory penalties, and reputational damage. Let’s explore what’s legal, what’s not, and how employees can protect their rights in the digital workplace.
Types of Employee Surveillance and Legal Considerations
Employers in New York often use various monitoring methods, including:
- Email and Internet Monitoring – Employers can monitor company-provided email accounts and internet activity, but they must inform employees in writing.
- Phone Call Monitoring – Businesses can listen in on work-related calls, but they cannot record personal conversations without consent.
- Video Surveillance – Employers can use video surveillance in public areas but cannot place cameras in restrooms, locker rooms, or other areas where employees expect privacy.
- GPS Tracking – Companies may track company-owned vehicles but cannot monitor an employee’s private vehicle without consent.
- Biometric Data Collection – The use of fingerprint or facial recognition systems is subject to New York City’s Biometric Identifier Information Law, which requires transparency and security measures.
New York employers must disclose electronic monitoring practices to employees, ensuring that workers understand what is being tracked and why.
New York’s Electronic Monitoring Law
As of May 7, 2022, New York’s Electronic Monitoring Law requires employers to notify workers when they monitor:
- Email communications
- Phone calls
- Internet activity
Employers must provide written notice upon hiring and obtain a signed acknowledgment. The notice should clarify the scope and purpose of the monitoring.
Failure to comply with this law can result in penalties from the New York Attorney General’s Office and potential legal challenges from employees.
What Surveillance Methods Are Prohibited?
Despite broad employer rights, certain surveillance practices are strictly prohibited in New York:
- Recording private conversations without consent – New York is a one-party consent state, meaning at least one person in the conversation must agree to recording.
- Monitoring personal devices without consent – Employers cannot track an employee’s private phone, laptop, or personal email account.
- Installing hidden cameras in private areas – Secret surveillance in restrooms, changing rooms, or break rooms violates privacy laws.
- Using surveillance for retaliation – Monitoring employees for union activity or whistleblowing is illegal under labor laws.
Employees who suspect illegal surveillance should document their concerns and seek legal advice.
How Employees Can Protect Their Privacy
While employers have the right to monitor workplace activity, employees can take steps to safeguard their privacy:
- Review your employee handbook – Look for company policies on electronic monitoring and workplace privacy.
- Use personal devices for private matters – Avoid using work email or company computers for personal communication.
- Be mindful of workplace conversations – Assume that emails, messages, and work calls may be monitored.
- Document any concerns – If you suspect invasive or illegal surveillance, keep records and consult a legal professional.
If an employer fails to comply with New York’s electronic monitoring laws, employees may have grounds for a complaint or legal action.
How Lipsky Lowe LLP Can Help
At Lipsky Lowe LLP, we concentrate solely on employment law in New York. We advocate for employees in privacy and workplace monitoring disputes. If you suspect that your employer has engaged in unlawful surveillance, neglected to provide notice, or retaliated against you for asserting your rights, our firm can help.
We provide legal guidance on:
- Challenging unauthorized surveillance – If an employer is monitoring private conversations or personal devices, we can assess legal violations and pursue action.
- Holding employers accountable for privacy violations – Employers who fail to comply with New York’s Electronic Monitoring Law can face significant consequences.
- Protecting employees from retaliation – f your employer targets you for union organizing, whistleblowing, or legal complaints, we will fight for your rights.
- Negotiating settlements or filing claims – We help employees seek damages or corrective action for privacy violations.
If you suspect your employer is monitoring you unlawfully, contact us today for a consultation. Let us help you defend your workplace privacy.